October 2015 // Volume 53 // Number 5 // Tools of the Trade // v53-5tt4
Assessing Impact of Online Delivery of Turfgrass and Landscape Information
Kansas State University's turfgrass Extension team delivers information via linked online resources that include a blog, emails, and social media. We recently surveyed users to assess who they are, what they learn, how they use information, overall impressions, as well as suggested improvements. Users learn how to identify and manage various pests, select plant materials, and where to access further information and training. They prefer an email as the portal to the information. They communicate the information with others. Survey respondents suggested several revisions to format and content.
Introduction and History
Online delivery of Extension programming is increasing, and Extension educators have been encouraged to incorporate digital tools (Kinsey, 2010). Internet resources can provide timely information to a larger audience while reducing travel costs and allowing flexibility for the end-user regarding when and how they access information (Kinsey, 2010). Blogs and other online resources have been used for a wide array of program areas and crop commodities, including grapes (Stafne 2012), apples (DiPietro & Miller, 2009), pecans (http://northernpecans.blogspot.com/), and others.
In 2007, the Kansas State University turfgrass Extension team developed a weekly email-based pdf newsletter about turfgrass diseases that was distributed to approximately 500 subscribers on a listserv. The newsletter soon broadened to include other turf and landscape topics, including weeds, insects, plant selection, irrigation, and fertilization, with an overall theme of integrated pest management. After a few seasons, subscribers requested a searchable, archived format, and some expressed difficulty opening the pdf documents. Therefore, the pdf newsletter was converted to a blog format, with various features evolving over time. Blogs are efficient mechanisms for information delivery in the turfgrass industry and offer the ability to track user metrics (Jones, Kaminski, Christians, & Hoffman, 2011).The blog, available at https://blogs.k-state.edu/turf/, serves as the content hub. The email newsletter reaches approximately 1,200 subscribers and functions primarily to drive users to content on the blog. We also use Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/KSUTurf) and Twitter (https://twitter.com/KSUTurf) to provide links to the blog as well as facilitate multi-directional engagement. Throughout the remainder of this article we use "newsletter/blog" to collectively refer to this package of online resources.
Assessment Goals and Survey Design
In fall 2014, we designed an online survey to evaluate the newsletter/blog. Nine questions gathered feedback on user characteristics, general reactions, knowledge gains, impacts on action/behavior, and suggestions for improvement. The project was submitted to the University Research Compliance Office and was designated exempt from further review. We designed the survey using Qualtrics (available to KSU faculty) and made it available via an anonymous survey link. The link was distributed through the email, Facebook, and Twitter. Several reminders were also sent to help increase participation. We received 94 responses.
Respondents were primarily based in Kansas (89%), with some in Missouri (7%) or other states (3%). Our audience represented a broad array of the turfgrass and landscape industries, with golf course management and lawn care as the largest sectors (Table 1).
|Golf course management||23%|
|Lawn care company||18%|
|School grounds/athletic fields||4%|
|Local Extension educator/agent||10%|
|Extension Master Gardener||3%|
|Chemical company (fertilizer/pesticide, etc)||7%|
|Greenhouse, nursery, or garden center||5%|
|Other (please describe)||9%|
One objective was to determine how users access the information. Most (78%) prefer to receive the weekly newsletter for blog links, but others prefer using social media or other methods (Table 2).
|Watch for the email newsletter, then click to articles of interest||78%|
|Follow on Facebook||5%|
|Subscription to the blog||6%|
|Other (please describe)||3%|
Another key objective was to learn about knowledge gains and application of that knowledge. Most respondents indicated that the newsletter/blog aided them in the identification of diseases, weeds, and insects (Table 3). Many respondents use the information to implement cultural practices and select and use pesticides.
|Diagnose disease problems||73%|
|Identify insect pests||63%|
|Diagnose abiotic/environmental stress problems in plants||37%|
|Manage weeds using cultural practices||52%|
|Manage insects using cultural practices||36%|
|Manage diseases using cultural practices||40%|
|Select and use chemicals for disease management||40%|
|Select and use chemicals for insect management||40%|
|Select and use chemicals for weed management||48%|
|Manage abiotic/environmental stress problems||30%|
|Make decisions about irrigation||26%|
|Select varieties for new plantings (turf ,trees, or ornamentals)||42%|
|Understand how to submit samples (disease, weed, or insect) for diagnosis||35%|
Another goal for the newsletter/blog is to raise awareness of trainings, publications, and other resources. Respondents indicated that they learned about these resources (Table 4).
|Question||Percent responding yes|
|Made me aware of new turf or landscape resources (print or electronic) from Kansas State University||85%|
|Made me aware of new turf or landscape resources from outside Kansas State University||55%|
|Made me aware of educational program opportunities (field days, conferences, pesticide credit trainings, etc)||86%|
We asked if users share information from the newsletter/blog. The majority of respondents, 87%, responded "Yes" to the question, "Has the K-State turf and landscape newsletter/blog helped you better communicate about turf or landscape topics with others (e.g., your supervisor, your employees, your clients, your neighbors, or others)?"
We solicited general assessments of the quality and usefulness of the newsletter/blog, and average scores were high (Table 5).
We asked two open-ended questions: "How can we improve the K-State turf and landscape email newsletter/blog? Please type your comments" and "Please provide any additional comments you would like to make." There were many generic positive comments about the information, like "keep it coming" or "we appreciate this resource" and a few comments on specific topics to cover. General suggestions included the following.
- Keep it simple and to the point. A lot of people in this field do not have formal education but need the guidance on how to do their jobs better.
- I wish more info could be printed like a newsletter so we can show our customers.
- Continue to improve the aesthetics to make it more and more palatable.
- Maybe an app sometime for quick smartphone reference
- Make it easier to navigate.
- I always print the newsletter off and make it available to the entire crew.
- Keep posting to Twitter and Facebook.
- Send the email on Monday or Tuesday instead of the end of the week.
- Include more information on lawn care, athletic fields, and lower-maintenance/lower budget sites
Lessons Learned and Future Work
As highlighted by Jones, Kaminski, Christians, & Hoffmann (2011), blogs provide a way to deliver timely content while facilitating conversation and development of relationships with end-users via comments and/or connections with other social media outlets. We have experienced similar advantages. Jones et al. (2011) also list challenges, including the necessity of frequent updating, availability and speed of Internet access, and user preference for other delivery methods. We have experienced the first challenge, but having two dedicated contributors helps overcome this, along with soliciting guest posts. We received no comments about the second challenge, regarding availability and speed of Internet access. Several users indicated a preference of an e-newsletter format over a blog, but none preferred traditional print delivery.
In the future, we will analyze metrics related to top search hits as well as monthly, weekly, and time-of-day views to optimize delivery. Other Extension blog authors have reported variation based on season or time of week (Stafne 2012; Jones et al. 2011). We will use the metrics to optimize engagement.
Based on the open-ended questions, we will send the email earlier in the week and explore the possibility of a more printable format. We will increase our coverage of lawn care, athletic fields, and lower-budget sites, along with the specific topics that respondents suggested.
This manuscript is contribution no. 15-400-J from the Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station.
DiPietro, L., & Miller, M. (2009). Extending expertise through conference calls and blogging. Journal of Extension [On-line], 47(6) Article 6TOT6. Available at: http://www.joe.org/joe/2009december/tt6.php
Jones, M. A., Kaminski, J. E., Christians, N. E., & Hoffmann, M. D. (2011). Using blogs to disseminate information in the turfgrass industry. Journal of Extension [On-line], 49(1). Article 1RIB7. Available at: http://www.joe.org/joe/2011february/rb7.php
Kinsey, J. (2010). Five social media tools for the Extension toolbox. Journal of Extension [Online], 48(5) Article 5TOT7. Available at: http://www.joe.org/joe/2010october/tt7.php
Stafne, E. T. (2012). Viticulture education via blogging. Journal of Extension [On-line], 50(6). Article 6TOT3. Available at: http://www.joe.org/joe/2012december/tt3.php