About JOE: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Following are answers to some frequently asked questions about the Journal of Extension (JOE). If you have further questions, see additional materials on the JOE website or contact the JOE editor, Debbie Allen, at email@example.com.
GeneralIs JOE a refereed journal?
Yes. Feature and Research in Brief submissions are reviewed by three members of the JOE peer reviewer committee in a double-blind review process. Ideas at Work submissions are reviewed by one member of the committee, also in double-blind review. Commentary and Tools of the Trade submissions are peer reviewed by the editor.
JOE has reached an important stage in the lengthy evaluation process required for attaining a journal impact factor. Journal impact factors are determined by Clarivate Analytics, which maintains the Web of Science citation indexing service and publishes journal impact factors annually in Journal Citation Reports. Journal impact factors are reported only for journals indexed in three Web of Science Core Collection indexes: Science Citation Index Expanded, Social Sciences Citation Index, and Arts and Humanities Citation Index. For many journals, a precursor to coverage in one of these flagship indexes, and accompanying receipt of a journal impact factor, is indexation in Web of Science Core Collection’s Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI). JOE is now indexed therein. Coverage in ESCI signifies that JOE meets various criteria applicable only to journals demonstrating a certain level of editorial quality and increases the discoverability of JOE's content and the visibility of JOE authors. Additionally, due to JOE's inclusion in ESCI, JOE authors with access to the Web of Science Core Collection database can track citation activity associated with their articles. Clarivate Analytics will continue to monitor citation activity for JOE as well as JOE's adherence to other requirements to determine JOE's eligibility for coverage in a flagship index.
Although impact factor is a widely recognized journal measure, other evaluative metrics exist. JOE has been assigned various impact metrics through Scopus, an abstract and citation database of vetted peer-reviewed publication outlets in which JOE is indexed. You can access these metrics on Scopus’s “Source details” page for JOE. There you also can perform a search to obtain metrics for other extension-related journals indexed in the Education category of the database for the purpose of comparison
Yes. See JOE Website Statistics for many answers to this question.
No. JOE is supported by the U.S. land-grant university system. Because the primary contributors to, and readers of, JOE are land-grant university employees, JOE does not assess submittal or page charges.
In addition to the editor, JOE operations are guided by a board of directors made up of about 20 members. Members represent the four geographic regions of the Extension system, the 1890 land-grant universities, the U.S. Department of Agriculture National Institute of Food and Agriculture, the Extension Committee on Organization and Policy, eXtension, several Extension professional organizations, and the JOE webmaster site institution. The JOE peer reviewer representative also serves on the JOE board.
JOE is always ready to admit good reviewers to the JOE peer review committee.
You can apply to become a JOE reviewer by sending the name and email address of a reference who can speak to your ability to serve as a reviewer and a file containing your curriculum vitae to JOE peer reviewer representative Robert Ricard at firstname.lastname@example.org.
The JOE editorial committee chair, peer reviewer representative, and editor serve as the committee to select JOE reviewers. They make their selections on the basis of the degree to which candidates meet the criteria for reviewers and the need to achieve balance across reviewers in terms of subject-matter expertise and geographical representation.
JOE reviewers review approximately six to 12 submissions per year. Their comments and critiques help JOE authors produce articles of the highest quality. To effectively perform this service, they must
- have breadth and depth of subject-area expertise,
- understand quantitative and qualitative research methodologies and value the unique contribution each makes to Extension scholarship,
- have published in JOE and/or other refereed journals or published works of similar rigor (e.g., book chapters, reviewed curricula),
- demonstrate excellent English grammar and writing skills, and
- be active or former Extension professionals.
Submission ProcessWhere can I find information about submitting a manuscript to JOE?
The JOE website contains a wealth of resources for authors interested in submitting manuscripts to JOE. Two places to start an exploration of these resources are the JOE Submission Guidelines and the Guidance for Authors page.
JOE has no submission deadlines. The only rule of thumb is that the sooner a manuscript is submitted, the sooner it will go through the sometimes lengthy review, revision, and publication process.
No. Outreach and adult-education professionals who do not hold formal Extension appointments may well have insights, information, and research results to share that would be of significant interest to JOE readers. However, articles submitted to JOE should display an understanding of Extension and discuss the topic within the context of Extension or with reference to Extension.
The time it takes for manuscripts to move through the JOE editorial review and peer review processes varies and is dependent on the rate of submissions and the conditions of manuscripts being submitted, in addition to other factors. For more information, see JOE Review and Publication Process.
Supported by the U.S. land-grant university system, the Journal of Extension (JOE) is the official refereed journal for U.S. Extension professionals. Most contributors to JOE are U.S. land-grant university employees, and the journal’s audience is U.S. Extension professionals and other outreach scholars. Articles published in JOE are focused on best practices for disseminating university-based research findings to the public and identify clear implications for U.S. Extension.
That said, JOE does publish articles about research and projects that are conducted in, or based on the contexts of, locations other than the United States and its territories if the applicable research or project has implications for U.S. Extension and those implications are made clear. Therefore, researchers and practitioners whose work occurred outside the United States may consider submitting the resulting manuscript to JOE but first should ensure that doing so makes sense. To increase their understanding of JOE, such authors should peruse the current issue and recent issues of the journal. They also should carefully examine JOE Submission Guidelines, JOE Review and Publication Process, and other materials for prospective JOE authors for additional information that will help them determine the appropriateness of submitting a manuscript to JOE. These authors should keep in mind that the journal publishes only manuscripts that elucidate implications for U.S. Extension, conform to the JOE Submission Guidelines, and have successfully undergone appropriate editorial and double-blind peer review.
JOE publishes reviews of books that have direct relevance for a broad Extension audience as Tools of the Trade articles. The submission, review, and publication process for a book review manuscript is the same as for any other Tools of the Trade submission.
JOE does not accept books for review and then solicit reviewers for them.
Manuscript FastTrack (MFT) is the online manuscript review system used by JOE. Unlike many other journals, JOE uses MFT for online review only and only for review of Feature, Research in Brief, and Ideas at Work submissions. Therefore, all authors must first submit their manuscripts to the editor, Debbie Allen, at email@example.com. The editor gives authors the information they need to upload their submissions to MFT once she has reviewed them and determined that they are suitable for double-blind review. For a fuller explanation, see JOE Review and Publication Process.
Manuscript FastTrack (MFT) is the online manuscript review system used by JOE. Prospective JOE authors and JOE reviewers who need to access MFT should go to http://joe.expressacademic.org/login.php and enter their user ID and password credentials to log in.
When authors and reviewers change positions, and thus email addresses, they must change their user information in MFT. If they don’t, important emails, such as those containing review results or review assignments, won’t reach them.
If you’re an MFT user who wants to change your user information in MFT, take the following actions:
- Log on to MFT.
- Click the "User preferences" tab to access your "User preferences" page.
- On your "User preferences" page, click "Change information/preferences" at the bottom of the page to access a form that allows you to edit your information.
- Make the necessary changes.
- Click "Change user info" at the bottom of the page.
If you encounter a problem in using MFT, contact FastTrack support, not the JOE editor. There is a link to FastTrack support on every page in MFT.
Format and UseWhen did JOE enter the electronic age?
JOE was first published electronically in 1994, after 30 years as a print journal.
JOE is published six times annually, near the end of February, April, June, August, October, and December.
JOE is a professional, refereed journal, and, as such, its back issues are preserved in their entirety. The intent of Extension Journal, Inc. is to maintain all issues of JOE in a readily available form. Multiple archives are maintained to ensure content security, information integrity, and long-term access.
Yes. When the editor notifies a corresponding author that a manuscript has been accepted for publication in JOE, the editor instructs the corresponding author to access the Journal of Extension Copyright Agreement and complete the form affirming compliance with the agreement. The agreement stipulates, among other things, that the work is original, that it violates no copyrights, that it has been submitted to no other journal, and that the manuscript’s copyright is fully transferred to JOE. If the corresponding author declines to affirm the agreement, the accepted manuscript will not be published in JOE.
Single copies of articles published in JOE may be reproduced in electronic or print form for use in educational or training activities. Inclusion of articles in other publications or electronic sources or systematic, large-scale distribution may be done only with prior electronic permission from the editor.
Yes. To support JOE authors in their scholarly commitment to share intellectual, creative work with peers, the Extension Journal, Inc. board of directors endorses institutional archiving of JOE articles, with a strong preference for using the URL of the online, html version of the article as the point of reference. Nonexclusive, noncommercial, onetime, single-use permission is granted for education and research only. Copyright notice, citation of original publication data, and a link to the JOE website are to be included as part of the archive.
Every JOE article from December 2008 forward is available in printable PDF format, and PDFs of earlier articles will be added to the website as time permits. These PDFs may be used for printing and may be placed on other websites with the permission of the JOE editor. If permission is granted, Extension Journal, Inc. requests that the PDF version of the JOE article be a hyperlink pointing to the PDF file on the JOE website so that usage and readership statistics can be tracked.
Example: If you wish to link to the PDF version of the August 2009 Feature article “Extension, the Land-Grant Mission, and Civic Agriculture: Cultivating Change,” add the following code to your website:
<a href="https://www.joe.org/joe/2009august/pdf/JOE_v47_4a1.pdf">Extension, the Land-Grant Mission, and Civic Agriculture: Cultivating Change v47-4a1 (pdf)</a>
If you would like to post a PDF of a JOE article, please contact the JOE editor at firstname.lastname@example.org.
No. JOE is a web-based journal, so authors and readers can print articles and entire issues directly from the web.
Several online databases index JOE articles, summarize their contents, and increase their discoverability. Those databases are Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI), Scopus, ERIC, and Cabells Whitelist.
ESCI is a selective multidisciplinary citation index and is part of the Web of Science Core Collection. Web of Science indexes are available to institutions and organizations through annual subscription. Coverage in ESCI signifies that JOE meets various criteria applicable only to journals demonstrating a certain level of importance and increases the visibility of JOE’s content and authors. Due to JOE’s inclusion in ESCI, JOE authors with access to the Web of Science Core Collection database can track citation activity associated with their articles.
Scopus is an abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed publication outlets available to institutions and organizations through annual subscription. A governing body uses a system of evaluation and validation to determine which journals to include in the database and reviews the indexed journals annually to ensure that quality standards are maintained.
ERIC (the Education Resources Information Center) is an Internet-based digital library of education research and information sponsored by the Institute of Education Sciences of the U.S. Department of Education. ERIC provides access to bibliographic records of journal and nonjournal literature from 1966 to the present. ERIC’s mission is to provide a comprehensive, easy-to-use, searchable Internet-based bibliographic and full-text database of education research and information for educators, researchers, and the general public.
Cabells Whitelist is a curated database of information on qualified academic journals of use to researchers, publishers, librarians, academics, and administrators. Journals included on the Whitelist address 18 disciplines.
Because JOE is published exclusively online, its articles have no page numbers. However, beginning with the first issue of 1984, articles published in JOE include article numbers. Article numbers from 1984 through 2008 are unique across a volume (or year) of the journal. Article numbers from 2009 onward are unique to each article. Most documentation systems have conventions governing the citation of electronic documents, including the use of article numbers, and readers are encouraged to consult them for guidance.